Showing posts with label Matthew Rabjohns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew Rabjohns. Show all posts

Monday, 5 August 2019

Who Reviews Meglos by Matt Rabjohns



"The point is, the Doctor doesn't get to Tigella!"
"Oh, but he does gentlemen, he does...We mustn't disappoint the Tigellans!"

Far from being a lacklustre season, season 18 was an incredibly strong farewell to Tom Baker as the Doctor. Over the course of seven wonderful years he had taken the show to the zenith of its popularity. But as the 80s began Doctor Who was seriously up against some serious viewing figure challenges like never before. The viewing figures for Season 18 were very low indeed. But this is by no means any indicator that the show was lagging. Because it was actually entering the 80s with quite some mature and fervent bang to be honest.

From the opening scene of Meglos though one can see that our wonderful main man of the moment, Tom himself, is in very distinctly poor health. He looks worn out and even haggard and it’s a true credit to his acting ability that he still gave his utmost to the role even when poorly and discontent with the show. The changeover in production had not sat well with Tom and so he reluctantly decided to leave. But with Meglos that happenstance is still five stories away.

In many ways Meglos is perhaps the most traditional of all the season eighteen stories. It has the megalomaniacal despot, this time though in the very distinctive form of Meglos. Meglos of course resembles a cactus in his natural Xeraphite form, but this cactus is one mean and nasty baddie indeed. It is a real pleasure that we get none other than Tom Baker playing Meglos too, and his performance is unsurprisingly rich and superb. There is a real vein of acidity in his performance of Meglos. Of course, with Tom playing both the role of the Doctor and Meglos its inevitable that we will have the epic meeting of the dopplegangers at the climax of the story. But as with every single doppleganger story before in the show, here it is a brilliant moment that caps off a very entertaining and very underrated romp indeed. Yes, and the Meglos make up looks phenomenally good on Tom, even though it must have been uncomfortable for him to perform in. What a trooper Tom, thank you!

Lalla Ward is hilarious when she leads the Gaztaks around in circles and makes fools of them. I love the streak of grit that runs through both of Romana's hearts. She is not a pushover; she could easily manage being the lead of her own show.

Bill Fraser is a wonderful henchman to Meglos, his General Grugger being rough and tough and sharp tongued. However, it is his own underling Brotadac, played with zeal and aplomb by the superb Frederick Treves who rather steals the scenes. It’s very amusing to think the writers of the story came up with the name Brotadac as a funny re arrangement of the words Bad Actor, with them seeing the character whilst writing it as perhaps being portrayed by some hammy or underwhelming actor! John Flannagan and Andrew McCulloch have since quoted Frederick as playing the role extremely well indeed, and one cannot disagree with them.

Another great yet understated performance is given by Christopher Owen as the Earthling. I wonder how any normal person would feel being kidnapped by Gaztaks and then taken over Meglos! Considering this very thing happens to his character, the Earthling still gets some good moments when he rebels and fights desperately to free himself of Meglos's spines. You root for him and eventually he does shake off Meglos. Although his last comment to the Doctor before he gets to go home is rather casually sexist and unnecessary. But this is only a very minor quibble and can pass by the way.

Jacqueline Hill! Oh, to see the wonderful actress back in a new Doctor Who story is very special and very, very welcome. There is absolutely nothing of Barbara Wright in Lexa. Lexa in fact starts out brash and perhaps bordering on the typical religious zealot, but when she knows she is the wrong for almost having the Doctor executed as a sacrifice she comes good. And then the poor women is shot in good old trusted "Let’s kill off the best characters in the show" brigade. But it is a chance to be savoured seeing Jacqueline light up the screen again after so long.

Colette Gleeson and Crawford Logan are equally diverting in their roles as Caris and Deedrix. their early run ins with Lexa are brilliantly charged and performed. They spice up the early segments of the story nicely.

Edward Underdown is rather kindly, and portrays the Tigellan leader Zastor with a huge amount of gentle pathos. He is unassuming and this helps him stand out as one of the more reasonable and approachable leaders of an alien society on another planet.

The story's use of Scene Sync is very impressive, and here works very well indeed, it’s a considerable leap forward from Colour Separation Overlay.

Perhaps the story's main shortfall is it does seem terribly short. The last three episodes of the story seriously underrun, the last in particular being a very meagre 18 minutes! The other shortfall is the poor realisation of the jungle, particularly the bell plant designs. They fail to remotely convince and its strange thinking these same designs come from the same show that a few months previously had produced a spectacular jungle in The Creature from The Pit. But despite the limitations of the budget, this story is still well paced, with a very strong central villain.

And just because this is the most traditional of the season 18 yarns, there is still some very good ideas floating around in this story. Especially the Chronic Hysteresis. How the Doctor and co escape from the trap set by Meglos too is wonderfully simple and yet comes over as a brilliant means of breaking the fold of time.

Meglos is one of those stories you never hear much spoken of. It has plenty of worth and merit. It’s a very solid story in a vastly underrated overall season. Tom Baker did not bow out with a whimper, he went out with a bang. And a resounding and brilliant bang at that...



Who Reviews Snakedance by Matt Rabjohns




The imaginative and fresh ideas that Christopher Bailey brought to the show when he wrote Kinda was amazing. The Mara was an extremely sinister and palpable menace, the embodiment of Dukkha especially was superbly effective in scaring the hell out of me when I was a young boy. I felt when watching Kinda that this is just begging for a sequel, and not just that, but a good sequel too. And I was delighted to find not soon afterward that there was indeed another Peter Davison story with the imaginative force from the dark places of the inside, and this time it would be taking the Mara back to its home planet and its roots.

Now I am almost certain that in many ways Snakedance is even better than Kinda, at least for me. The first major improvement of course is the look of the final serpent in part four. It is still not absolutely brilliant, but it is a whole lot more convincing than the decidedly awful realisation of the serpent in Kinda.

The spotlight given to Tegan in these two stories gives Janet Fielding the space to act better than she does in all her other Doctor Who appearances. In Kinda we saw her have a few moments possessed by the evil of the Mara, but this was really only a delicious little snippet. Here in Snakedance we are treated to the best of her controlled malevolence, and Janet is brilliant to watch. From her surprisingly catty GO AWAY! To her absolutely chilling performance whilst in the Fortune Tellers booth, Janet proves her mettle as one of the finest actresses ever at conveying the core of being possessed by a malign will. In the entire history of the show the only other woman to come close to matching Janet for palpability in the possession department is Elisabeth Sladen. I've never been so unnerved by a good girl going bad as I was when watching Janet in Snakedance. She truly steals the show with a brilliant and highly nuanced performance of demonic take over.

It is good to see a young Martin Clunes, and it’s a relief he does not play the show for laughs like something out of Men Behaving Badly. In fact, he plays the role of Lon totally straight and gives quite the performance, and he works brilliantly besides Janet Fielding throughout this story.

It is also a wonderful piece of TV to see no other than Brian Miller, aka LIs Sladen's husband, as the hapless stall owner Dugdale. He puts in a brilliant performance that is credible and it’s sad when he gets his mind burn out by the Mara so soon in the story.

What is also very good about this story is that it is not resolved in the typical way. Several Doctor Who stories villains are defeated by strong action. But that is not the case with this story. Here the Manifestation of the Mara is only defeated by the Doctor using the skills of the Snakedancer Dojjen to locate the still point within himself. So, a clean mind free of hate and misery and lies is what puts the refined evil of the Mara in its place.

Another point of congratulation has to be for the way this story embroils several differing nods to differing belief systems, particular Buddhist and Christian themes, without mocking those belief systems at all. All too often on TV shows we see plenty of belief systems being ridiculed or made fun of, and this is nothing but a turn off for me. I was always brought up to respect the beliefs and cultures of others, and it is a real decent change to see some different cultural references being used in Doctor Who without them being a source of jokes and disrespect. In fact, the subtle way the themes come over is to the story's credit no end. Most people don’t like being preached at, but when good moral and decent points are made in a programme it’s always a plus point for me.

Every character in this story is extremely well refined and characterised. We have the niave but charming Lady Tanha, played with charm by Colette O'Neil. Then we also have the added plus point of John Carson appearing as the aloof and brash Ambril. A classic scene is when he realises that the sixth face of delusion is his own whilst trying on a superbly realised headdress, and he barks at the Doctor to get out for him pointing this out to him! Then we have the reasonable and approachable Jonathon Morris as Chela, who works well with the Doctor and Nyssa in their quest to rid Manussa of the plague of the Mara.

Peter Davison is at the top of his game. And it's a refreshing change to see intelligence and thought being used to defeat a menace rather than outright fights and action. The variety of Doctor Who stories always has to be applauded. Never once did the show stagnate in the classic run, it’s part of the reason why the show has lasted as long as it has.

And one must never forget the presence of Nyssa. It’s so good that Sarah Sutton here gets to wear a different costume for once other than her normal trakenite garb. She looks pretty and charming in her multicoloured skirt and top here, and she is always wonderful as the character of Nyssa too.

Snakedance is one of the series finest presentations of a sequel, it is nothing like its predecessor Kinda, and it in fact achieves every goal that a decent sequel should have. It builds upon the foundation of Kinda, and honestly grows it so well. Kinda was excellent enough on its own, but the sequel for me is even stronger. Could we ever be in for a third story to make up a trilogy? One feels the Mara is a menace that could easily be expanded upon even more. But if we are to only have Kinda and Snakedance, then one seriously can have no complaints at all. The Mara really encapsulates well the darkness of the mind. The Mara stories stand as two incredibly strong Peter Davison shows, perhaps maybe even the cream of his era even, if it just be for their uniqueness and use of more than just overblown action to tell a very intelligent and gripping and very well paced four episodes of Doctor Who.

I have no idea why Christopher Bailey never appeared again after this story. He had such a fertile and rich way of thinking. He stands as a brilliantly fresh and creative writer and Doctor Who could have taken more stories from him. Just the kind of writer that brings nothing but benefits to the wonderful show....

Who Reviews The Green Death by Matt Rabjohns



A story that shines amongst a season of other hugely popular and amazing stories. Yet there is something about the Green Death that sets it apart from all the other stories of season 10. And I do believe I know what it might be that gives this story its unique feel, and it’s not just a single reason.

The first reason is that this is grounded on Earth, and actually there are no alien monsters or foes of that sort. What we get in the Green Death is an expertly crafted story where it is human error that is the major error. Poisoning of the land, which was of course a major passion of producer Barry Letts, and quite right too. The mess we have made of this planet is totally appalling.  Another aspect of the uniqueness is this is most certainly a story that is not farfetched at all. In fact, in some places of the world the mutation of wildlife and crops really does happen and is totally horrendous and so sad. The moral core of the Green Death is a tremendous strength. It is rather like Season 7 with its far more adult method of story weaving and the effort that goes into making a brilliant story like this one is.

The second reason this story stands out is because the farewell to Jo as a companion is so beautifully handled. It is understated and not stupidly over the top and the final scenes of the Doctor's leaving with a single tear cascading down his cheek is just a totally superb way to end the season. It’s an emotional end to a brilliant and innovative season of the show. And it is a testament to the production team that a story exploring pollution and simple human mistakes works so superbly.

Michael Briant always was a very reliable Doctor Who director. His input towards the show was amazing and all of his stories I really enjoy. The Green Death I think I would easily call him crowning achievement with the show. The sense of inherent realism and drama woven throughout this story is utterly astonishing.

The Cast of the story are all just perfect too. There is not one feeble performance. The standard of the performances enhances a brilliant script from Barry Letts and Robert Sloman so much in fact that this story still oozes the same feeling and resonance with me today.

Jerome Willis is cast so three dimensionally as Stevens. He makes the part totally real. He is devilishly good in the role, and a character you easily love to hate. But what Barry and Robert do with Stevens is a lovely little flip. In the final scenes of Steven's when he has gazed into the Metebelis Crystal and seen the error of his ways, you actually do feel a pang of remorse for him when the camera zooms in on his tear rimmed eyes the moment before he dies and takes the mad computer BOSS with him.

John Dearth's voice is used to utterly brilliant heights as BOSS. He is totally the right choice for the computer with his megalomaniacal streak. And yet he gives the computer a ful character, and when he is humming or singing or getting angry you think, yes, this thing has grown sentient and its deadly. BOSS is one of the best uses of computers in the show ever.

Stewart Bevan is also remarkable as Clifford Jones. You totally side with his characters fierce moral stance on what muck we are poisoning the planet with. Lessons of conservation and preservation of life need to be heeded and understood. And this story just brings this moral fibre to us in such an engaging and believable way. The scenes where he comforts Jo over the loss of Bert down the mine are utterly beguiling and the warmth in the heart of this fan viewer is near to boiling and bubbling over with joy at the brilliance of Katy Manning and Stewart.

It is also great to see Mike Yates get the chance to go undercover and its obvious Richard Franklin is relishing the opportunity to do something a bit different with the character. He does a fantastic job in this story and his character is given some really good scenes indeed. This is a very good story for his character indeed.

Then our reliable and adorable Sergeant Benton comes up with the answer to the situation of the maggots. "Could it be something it ate?" he remarks and then Nancy strikes gold and points to the Professor's hybrid fungus on the table.

The Maggots in this story are also one of the finest designs of the Jon Pertwee era. They look so real and their hissing is a brilliant touch. It strikes fear into my heart even now when the maggot springs on Hinks and the Professor. They are never seen as less than a very palpable threat. The underground mine shots of the maggots growing and hissing at the climax to part Two is another of those classic Doctor Who cliff-hangers. The maggots look vulgar and nasty all the way through the story. Even the dragonfly isn’t that bad either, and looks extremely impressive actually.

Perhaps the only tinniest of quibbles comes with UNIT not thinking to post a guard on the egg when it’s brought back to the Nuthutch. This is just not a scenario that rings true. If you had an egg that big and had already seen the maggots and how malignant they are, no way on earth would you leave it unguarded. And to think that not even the Doctor seems to think of this does seem a little bit strange. Mind you, when in the middle of such an adventure maybe some things would accidentally slip from your mind, so maybe I am just being a bit picky.

But one tinsey little niggle does not withhold this story from one of the absolute die hard best stories the show ever put on screen. It is one of the best paced six parters in the show’s history, it not once feels laboured or slow. In fact, it all feels so breathtakingly real and present even to this day.

Yes, the Green Death still has its lessons to teach. The themes raised are even more relevant now than ever. One last thing of note is the Blu Ray Collection 10 Boxset is wonderful for the Behind the Sofa segments where it’s so beautiful to see Katy Manning and John Levene and Richard Franklin openly relishing the chance to watch these gems again. The way they get emotional at the climax is so heart-warming. The Green Death too must have been so difficult what with the shock of Roger Delgado's death still sinking in and what with Katy leaving.

That The Green Death is cited often as a classic is no mistake. It must totally is one absolute belter of a Doctor Who story. It succeeds on every possible level.





Who Reviews Warrior's Gate by Matt Rabjohns




"Run Doctor! Scurry off back to your blue box. You're like all the rest: lizards when there's a man's work to be done. I'm sick of your kind. Faint-hearted, do-nothing, lily-livered deadweights. This is the end for all of you. I'm finally getting something done! Hahaha hahahahaaaaa!!!!"

John Nathan Turner and Christopher H Bidmead wished for Doctor Who to be taken into more "Real science" territory after what they considered a far too jokey period of the show which had been season 17. The did not completely remove the humour, but they did lance a huge amount of it out of their debut season together. They also drove the stories towards being more serious, which is a good thing. Its then somewhat just a little paradoxical that "Warrior's Gate" does actually possess the most humour of all the season 18 stories. But within this story the humour comes from the drama, rather than being grafted on.

"Warrior's Gate" is probably the most science-oriented story of the season. It can be actually a tad confusing if you're not concentrating fully. But if you are fully alert, then you will discover just how unique and interesting this story is.

Steve Gallagher is a very talented and gifted writer. Here he takes the themes of a contracting section E Space and runs with it and presents us with a very very stark and stand out story indeed. This is helped no end by the inventive and creative direction of Paul Joyce, although one understands that this story was not one with a smooth production at all. Paul Joyce was apparently far more of a visual filmic director, and had no idea of the manic schedule that was the usual Doctor Who story recording of the 80s. In fact, he was even sacked at one point by John Nathan Turner and some segments of the story are directed by Graeme Harper. That a superb story somehow manages to emerge from all this hassle is a definite credit to everyone involved in its making.

The Tharils are a particularly good and well realised race of aliens, that are given a good amount of background, yet still have a lot of mystery surrounding them. They are not out and out heroes, not totally black hearted individuals either. Their greyness is what makes them interesting. They are in no way shape or form the typical Doctor Who alien race. In fact, little of Warrior's Gate is typical Doctor Who. Jeremy Gittins appears as Lazlo too, long before his more memorable role as the Vicar in "Keeping Up Appearances". David Weston however is the most notable and present of the Tharil, and he is sublime in the role.

The casting on the story is also spot on. Kenneth Cope is a brilliant Packard, and any shadows of his Carry On Film appearances or the suchlike are totally absent from his performance here. He plays Packard real and straight-faced all the way through.

Clifford Rose is the man of the hour though. His Rorvik is delicious. He's thoroughly nasty through and through. He has no ounce of decency in him. He is totally self-centred and acidic and he really stands out as one of the more memorable Doctor Who baddies. Actually, his slightly bonkers laugh towards the end of the story is very weirdly unsettling. He is definitely in the ranks of the best.

The Gundan Robots are also another well-designed set of robots, with their voices being particularly effective. They look mean, tall and command attention.

Another striking aspect of the story is the extravagant visuals. It does help to make the story stand out, but not like a sore thumb, rather more like a proud and exuberant thumb! The visions of the Doctor in his gorgeous burgundy ensemble moving past black and white shots of gardens and castles is amazingly effective on screen and looks totally unique.

The only major gripe with this story is the horrifically rushed goodbye to Romana as a character. Honestly, I can’t help feeling that Lalla Ward deserved a far better exit. However, the Doctor crowning her as the "Noblest Romana of them all!" is a lovely farewell line to this popular and much-loved companion. However at least she gets a good cause to follow, in that she leaves to help Biroc free his people from the universe of E space, and K9 stays with her too to lend a probe. K9's exit was also bittersweet for a lot of younger fans who adored the metal mutt.

Perhaps another tiny gripe is that Matthew Waterhouse does get rather side-lined in this script, and doesn’t really justify his presence within the story really. But Matthew again is not half as bad as he is frequently portrayed as being, and he has some very amusing interactions with K9 all along through this story.  And he is already proving himself worthy as a reliable assistant, especially when he gets the Doctor out of trouble with Rorvik.

Another small but worthy note to mention is the guns in this story for once don’t look flimsy and stupid and unconvincing. They look to be made of real decent heavy metal so when Rorvik holds one to the Doctor's cheek you believe for once this gun could cause some real harm. The designers did well on this story to say the least.

So, the Doctor and Adric finally escape the confines of E Space and head back into the real universe of N Space. But the end of an era is approaching, and Warrior's Gate stands as a very original and different story to help make Tom Baker's last year very memorable and very entertaining indeed.



Friday, 5 July 2019

Articles Welcome to Issue 71 - WATNOW: From Out of the Rain



Contents Guide

Articles
About Us Updates
Where Are They Now Cast?

Big Finish Reviews+
Paternoster Volume 1
Tenth Doctor Adventures Vol 3
UNIT Incursions
By Tony J Fyler

Beyond the TARDIS
The Worzel Book by Matthew Rabjohns
Years & Years by DJ Forrest
The Watcher Productions: Strange Tales Video reviews
SJA: The Last Sontaran by Andrew Allen

Connections
Years and Years

Interviews
Taking Confessions with Jason Arnopp

The Mothership
Rainbow Across Her Hearts Poem by Matt Rabjohns
Ode of the Third Doctor by Matt Rabjohns

Fans Fiction
The Strangest of Days by Jeff Goddard
The Lady C Adventures: The Mystery of Mayhurst Manor
By Sarah Cambridge

TW Reviews
Sync by Tony J Fyler
Sargasso by Tony J Fyler

Who Reviews
Delta and the Bannermen by Alex Wylie
Attack of the Cybermen by Alex Wylie
Curse of the Fenric by Matt Rabjohns
The Monster of Peladon by Matt Rabjohns
Time and the Rani by Matt Rabjohns



Editor’s Note

This past month (June) saw me toying with what to do with the website. I’d been thinking for a while how to bring new life into it, and quite by chance, at the end of the month, I was rewarded with three new writers – Alex Wylie, Matt Rabjohns and Jeff Goddard. Jeff has written for us before in the Fans Fiction section and delivers us yet another Doctor Who story, which you are going to require hankies for. Check out their blurbs on the About Us page – links on the Contents above.  

We bid a farewell today – to our wonderfully talented fictional writer, Christopher E. Fain who steps down from writing for us to work on his own projects, and we wish him all the very best for the future. Chris kept us entertained with his writing works ‘Heaven and Nature Sing’ and ‘Tango of the Exiles’, which encapsulated Torchwood with Sherlock and Doctor Who, all rolled into one, and every single story, I couldn’t put down. Lyn was one of my favourites. I hope one day that Chris is able to create more character stories and send one over to us to read and share.

We have so many new reviews to entertain you with. I was going to write one for Un Bore Mercher, but I think I shall wait until Keeping Faith returns this Summer, and post it then. Only fair, really.
It’s bloody good though – the series. Will there be a third, I wonder?

What were your thoughts on the Russell T Davies’ new drama series Years and Years? Check out our thoughts on the series, and feel free to add your own comments below the article. Also, pop on over to our Connections this month and find out just how many cast and crew names you recognise from Years and Years!

Tony has been once again busy with the Big Finish Reviews, and our new reviewers have plenty to say in Who Reviews.

Congratulations as ever to the winners of the recent Soap Awards – especially to our friend Nathan Sussex, who bagged the Soap Villain award for his role as Buster, in Hollyoaks. Will he reprise his role for a return visit?

So, with so much to read this month, I best not keep you.

Croeso i, Issue 71 – WATNOW: From Out of the Rain

Djak


Thursday, 4 July 2019

Beyond The TARDIS The Worzel Book by Matt Rabjohns



Written by Stuart Manning

There are not many factual books based on TV series nowadays that explore, absolutely, everything you could think of to do with the series they are written for! Even with a series such as Doctor Who there are countless avenues to explore because of the boundless format of the show. Then there are other series, that may not have had as long a series run as shows like Doctor Who, but are still just as splendid and marvellous today as they were back when they were first made. They are fondly and avidly remembered by thousands across the globe. Some factual books tend to focus on one area of a programme, and miss a huge deal from all the other avenues left untouched. But that is most certainly not the case with Stuart Manning's absolutely sublime loveletter to that wonderful children's show, Worzel Gummidge.

The Worzel Book may just be the most thorough and beautiful factual book that has ever been written about ANY TV show. There is nothing that is not dwelt upon in this TARDIS interior of a book. From Barbara Euphan Todd's original books, to the other stage and radio plays that have been performed since the infancy of radio. From the development of Jon Pertwee's masterstroke of a character into the incredibly successful series it was to the New Zealand "Down Under" series that followed after the first four series in the UK.

This book is a magical maze of the amazing. The photography is something one would have thought could only be dreamed of. The black and white photos or the rich colour plates are lovingly displayed. The depth of production information is boundless. Even each individual episode's goofs are written up and described, as are the dates and transmission times of every single episode. There are some wonderful interviews with the surviving members of the cast. Honestly cannot fault the breadth of sheer knowledge encased within these pages.

Stuart Manning must have taken such a massive amount of time whilst compiling this book. It is most certainly not a churn them out in a few months’ effort. This book has had time taken over it, to make sure it is the best it could possibly be. It most certainly surpasses all other factual books on programmes that I have ever read. It's a veritable monster among books.

Perhaps, maybe, this book is definitely aimed at the mature fan though. Children would easily get lost within the huge amount of information found in here. But if, as I, you are a keen and avid fan of Worzel Gummidge, then the old cliché that this is a "Must have" could not be truer if it tried.

It's time to revisit the good old days of Children's TV at its best. To see the late great Jon Pertwee don his carrot nose and moth-eaten scarecrow jacket and run amok in either Scatterbrook or Zoo Neeland! If you are a Worzel fan, and you don’t have this book, then you are missing the cream of your collection. A Worzel Gummidge collection without The Worzel Book is like a salad without watercress....

The Worzel Book is more than just a mere book. It is the ultimate compendium of all things Worzel Gummidge. It's a testament to Barbara Euphan Todd, who created the character. It's a testament to Keith Waterhouse and Willis Hall, who adapted the show for TV. It's a testament to James Hill, who directed almost every episode of the cherished show. It's also a fine memorial to Jon Pertwee and Una Stubbs, forever immortalized as Worzel and the mean old Aunt Sally. This is the Bible of Worzel Gummidge, yes that is the nearest decently descriptive word I can give to fully explain how good this book truly is....

Who Reviews Time and the Rani by Matt Rabjohns



When any TV show is beset with the problems of emerging and recovering after an imposed hiatus, it is always going to struggle. Especially when a lead actor in the role is rather unceremoniously dropped from the role for no readily good reason in the case of Colin Baker. Problems like these can become insurmountable. With regards to the regeneration scene pre-opening titles sequence it is jarringly obvious that Colin Baker is no longer in residence. Sylvester McCoy has the tricky job of convincing us that at first this is the sixth Doctor. But some rather dodgy effects work totally hampers his efforts, to make this the poorest ever regeneration sequence in the show's history. The reason for the regeneration is also left rather ambiguous and not explained well in the story. In the Target Book we are told it’s the TARDIS's tumultuous buffeting that causes his regeneration. This then begs the secondary question of how Mel is then also still alive and soon is shown to be unharmed by the experience.

If a wonderful show though can get past a slightly stumbling start, and then produce a rather splendid and fun story for Doctor Who, then one simply has to applaud it. Time and the Rani actually possesses much that is very good. For starters, the performance of Sylvester McCoy once he has actually assumed his mantle as the Seventh Doctor is remarkably polished. There is no "Let's see how long he takes to settle into the role" at all. He is immediately a totally new and fresh incarnation of the Doctor. Of course, his performance would be further developed over the course of his three-year stint, but for a first stab at being Doctor he succeeds admirably.

There are two distinct aspects to the Seventh Doctor. His clown act, and his devious master manipulator act. During his era these aspects of his character emerge at different times. Time and the Rani is definitely focused on the former of these two aspects. The Doctor in Time and the Rani is actually very similar to the Second Doctor, in that he is bumbling, and that he mashes up his proverbs horrendously. Yet the darker tones do emerge, especially in his first meeting with the Rani before he is drugged by the Rani. His scathing and unrelenting downers on the Rani's past actions are delivered with great aplomb. Yet there are also all the common traits of the Doctor present. He is always against the evil plans of his foe, and he is always protective of his companions.

Bonnie Langford seems to be a person few people remember from the series. Her character of Melanie Bush certainly could have been written far more respectfully, but with the material she was given Bonnie always does well.  But the fact that she is supposed to be a keen computer programmer never really is shown within her stories she shared either with Colin Baker or Sylvester McCoy. Melanie does have the tendency to quick panic as well, which can be just a tad wearing with her very severe high-pitched screaming.

To be joined by Kate O'Mara as the Rani is also much to the story's benefit. Time and the Rani can be said to possess a high amount of rather implausible science inherent in the scripting. But if you can give the main adversary's character to a sublime and respected actress like Kate, then you know that despite some of the plotting silliness along the way, you will get a professional and highly watchable performance. Kate O'Mara deals incredibly well with the Rani. She has a certain charm that makes one feel beneath all this mad, self-centred scientist, beats the hearts of a proper three-dimensional character. So many evil baddies in shows such as Doctor Who can become run of the mill and stilted and dull so easily, but Kate never falls into this trap. She is one actress who does deserve the mantle of scene stealer. She catches the eye. Kate deserved to come back to the show, a whole lot more could have been made of the Rani.

Also helping things no end are the other castings within this story too. Donald Pickering turns in a very understated and respectable performance as the tortured leader of the Lakertyan race. Wanda Ventham also directs a superb amount of emotion into the role of Faroon, the mother of Sarn who is callously murdered by the Rani. The scenes of her discussing the prospects of life without their daughter with Beyus are moving and charged.

The Tetraps are not the most well realised monsters to have appeared in the show. But they are utilised better than many alien races have been in the show before this story. That they are able to turn the tables on the Rani at the story's final hurdle does make for an amusing ending. Hanging upside down had to have been extremely uncomfortable for the men who had to act in this manner for the story.

Script wise solely, it may never be a good idea to pick apart this story. It’s got some very very strange science that will not hold up to any kind of scrutiny. It’s sometimes convoluted, sometimes wacky. Yet the sense of joyous introduction to the new Doctor overrides the shortcomings in the science in every minute of this narrative.

So, Time and The Rani does suffer from its fair share of problems, some of them unavoidable. With the weight of Doctor Who's very insecure future hanging over this story it is good that any decent kind of story emerged at all. Inspite of these problems though, the story has many very good sections. Kate O'Mara as the Rani is one, with her zany dressing up as Mel to achieve her own devious ends. Any actress who can plausibly deliver a line like "I have the Loyhargill, nothing can stop me now" without inducing fits of giggles has to be applauded. The characterisation of the Lakertyans is another decent aspect to the story too. Despite the flimsy regeneration, there are also some rather impressive effects. Particularly the Rani's spherical death traps look credible and work extremely well on screen.

The cliff hangers in this story too are definitely dramatic and well done. Mel's falling into one of the Rani's traps is a very diverting and certainly perilous moment. The Doctor being surrounded by the Tetraps in their dank under cave in Part two is suitably claustrophobic. Sylvester McCoy deals well being surrounded by so many ugly tongues flicking towards his face. Part Three with the Doctor subdued and plugged in to add to the superbrain in the Rani's centre of operations too seems very cinematic and superbly driven.

Time and the Rani will never once win Doctor Who's most wonderful story award. But it is still worthy of revisiting if only for its sense of mischievous fun and for watching Sylvester McCoy just step into the role of the Doctor like it is the easiest thing in the universe. The Seventh Doctor would go on to have more memorable and epic adventures, but as a base one story, Pip and Jane Baker managed to make an effective yarn that is simply full of wonderfully bonkers theories and concepts. Amidst the good fun though there are some effecting and very well played scenes indeed. Time and the Rani will also never deserve the mantle of Doctor Who's worst story ever transmitted. It has far too much rich performance in it for it to be labelled thus so. If you can accept that this is Doctor Who done primarily for light relief and good humour, then you should love this story.

Who Reviews The Monster of Peladon by Matt Rabjohns





"The Citadel of Peladon, Sarah! One of the most interestingly-"
"Oh no it isn't, is it Doctor?"
"No, not exactly..."
"No! It's not your precious citadel at all, it's another rotten, gloomy old tunnel!"

So, fusses Sarah Jane Smith as the Doctor makes his return to Peladon fifty years after the events of his first adventure there. A lot has changed on the planet since that time, and then again nothing much has changed at all. Peladon has now joined the Galactic Federation, but things are not working out well for the planet at all.

Peladon as a planet is at once one of the strongest realised planets. the caves and interior of the citadel are superbly rich and give the story a very realistic feel and tone. The feeling of medieval corridors and flambeaus is a rich tapestry in which to set a truly decent story. All credit must go to the set designers. The setting feels totally authentic.

The Monster of Peladon is a story that never seems to garner much applause or commendation. It is frequently stated as a dull and tedious rehash of the earlier Curse of Peladon. But this easy classification is unfair and not true at all. There is a whole lot of merit within this six part adventure.

Firstly, the cast is of an exceptional quality. Frank Gatliff as Ortron is arrogant and unyielding. He performs the role with a hge amount of aplomb and zeal and relish. Nina Thomas portrays the slightly niave, youthful Queen wonderfully too. The notion of a female struggling with what is usually only a man's job on Peladon is a vein that she handles perfectly well. In fact, her innocence and charm are totally beguiling and instantly makes you like her.

Donald Gee makes a fine return to Doctor Who after his first appearance with Pat Troughton in The Space Pirates. It has been amusingly reported that Donald thought maybe his appearance on the show was a curse for the two lead actors, as both left in the next story after the one, he had appeared in! That is most assuredly not the case Donald! Haha! In fact, the performance Donald gives here is understated, so much so that he luls you into genuinely thinking he's a goodie, when in reality he turns out to be a snake. It's a supreme performance, wonderfully judged.

Another two prime performers are Ralph Watson as Ettis and Rex Robinson as Gebek. Whilst Ralph injects total hot-headed venom into his performance as Ettis as he descends into madness throughout the story, culminating in a pretty brutal beating bestowed on the Doctor when he tries to make him see sense.  Gebek is a more restrained and approachable character,and Rex works so well with Jon Pertwee.

Alan Bennion makes his last performance as the twisted Ice Lord Commander Azaxyr. Shades of the sadistic Slaar of the Seeds of Death run through this similarly dispicable villain. Azaxyr is a memorable and worthy foe for the Doctor and the Peladonians. Sonny Caldinez makes his fourth appearance as the Ice Lord's underling Sskel. Sonny is still the only man to have appeared in all four classic era Ihce Warrior tales. A little known fact of the Monster of Peladon was that the voices in this story for the Ice Martians were provided by the Producer Barry Letts! The Ice Warriors again make a brilliant foe.

The story also has several very memorable moments of merit. All scenes with Alpha Centauri as voiced by Ysanne Churchman are charming. The Haemaphrodite Hexapod is impossible to dislike. She may be slightly cowardly, but she has a hell of a lot of spirit. And Ysanne's voice is just wonderful for the character.

Elisabeth Sladen has to be commended again in this story too. She always seemed to be far better served in what her character contributed in a story when she was opposit Jon Pertwee. Later on, she was rather reduced when she was next to Tom Baker. But in The Monster of Peladon there are plenty of brilliant Sarah moments. particularly her talk with the Queen on Women's Liberation. Then later her portrayal of being grieved at the Doctor's apparent death is superbly performed. A special scene of when her tear falls on the Doctor's face is a brilliant scene. And her cry of shock as the Doctor's eyes open at that exact moment is brilliant acted. A definite favourite moment.

Some could apply some moral objections to the Doctor using the heat ray of the Aggedor Statue back against the Ice Warriors. But when in a life or death situation, what other real avenues could he possibly have taken? The Doctor knows Azaxyr would wipe out everyone in his way without a quarm, and the only way is to fight back and try to halt the Ice Warriors plans to steal the trisilicate for the neferious use of Galaxy Five!

The rough ride the Doctor goes through in this story too is pretty stark. He gets attacked by guards, gets arrested, gets brutally beaten up, then subjected to mental agony by Eckersley's pattented alarm system! Sometimes one wonders why the Doctor puts up with this constant bad treatment in all his travels. We have to be glad his spirit of compassion and his belief in good win out over all these impediments!

There are a few tiny flaws, but these are not detracting to the flow of the story at all. There is the blatantly obvious face of Terry Walsh doubling for Jon in the fight scene with Ettis, and Max Faulkner as a Peladonian is killed twice, but maybe its identical twin brothers?! Once you can even see the feet of Stewart Fell protruding from the bottom of the Alpha Centauri costume! But this was a show always made at speed and on a very tight budget.

For all the little goofs, this still doesn’t stop this story from being actually very action packed and very well paced. This does not feel like the usual six parter, as it never once feels protracted. In fact, this story doesn’t feel as endlessly talkative and static as the Curse of Peladon.

The story also ends on a bit of sad downer, as Aggedor is killed when defending the Queen against the criminal Eckersley. One is also hugely amused by Sarah's asking the Doctor whether he should truly consider Queen Thalira's offer of being her new chancellor and the Doctor grabs her ear and pulls her into the TARDIS, with Sarah protesting but laughing at the same time. It’s an amusing way to finish a very finely crafted story indeed. It is not the dull rehash of its earlier prequel. It is a very strong sequel and surely cements Peladon as a highly memorable segment of the Jon Pertwee era.