Showing posts with label Third Doctor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Third Doctor. Show all posts

Sunday, 13 June 2021

Big Finish Reviews+ The Third Doctor Adventures, Volume 7 by Tony J Fyler


 

“I’ve put all my eggs in the one basket.”

“Well that’s fine… supposing no-one steals the basket.”

The Brigadier and the Third Doctor there from The Time Warrior.

Ironically, the Brig is in much the same situation in the first story in this seventh Third Doctor box set, The Unzal Incursion.

Written by Mark Wright and set during the Doctor’s first, rather more spiky year as UNIT’s scientific advisor, The Unzal Incursion has a lot of the flavour of that year, with a little evolution from the 1970s. Liz Shaw (played by Daisy Ashford, daughter of Caroline John) with a frankly uncanny rightness of tone, has been leading a project to give the Earth a long-range warning system to pick up any alien wrong ’uns heading our way. As soon as it goes live, the Invasion Of The Week that was later to become a staple of the show becomes much more difficult to achieve.

Which is as good a reason as any for a bunch of alien wrong ’uns to want to knock it out or control it. The Hotspur Network, as it’s rather catchily called, becomes the focus on the Unzal Incursion, but like a lot of the best stories from the Liz Shaw season, the threat is already here. With a hint of Inferno around the edges, almost overnight, UNIT is compromised from within. Previously perfectly loyal officers go over to the enemy. And the Doctor, Professor Shaw and the Brigadier are forced onto the run, with all the forces of a hostile UNIT on their tails.

Chases in Bessie, chases in helicopters (with Lethbridge-Stewart in the pilot’s seat), sonic weapons, mass brainwashing, all the good stuff from early Pertwee-era Who is here, with a cast who frankly sound like they’re having the time of their lives. There’s an incredible zing between all the main players, Tim Treloar as the Third Doctor anchoring the piece with ever-increasing confidence and a vocal Pertwee stride, Jon Culshaw as the Brigadier sounding like he’s got the job he was born to play, and Daisy Ashford fitting in perfectly as Professor Shaw.

There’s an interesting question posed in the sub-text of The Unzal Incursion – at what point do your actions stop being your responsibility? There’s a good deal of brainwashing involved in getting UNIT to turn on its leader, and the question is raised of whether simply being brainwashed is defence enough for those who do unconscionable deeds, or whether at some point a line is drawn and responsibility allocated for not fighting a difficult personal fight to escape the brainwashing.

Along the way, there’s some excellent Liz Shawing, of the king you’d love to have seen on screen. There’s a classic Third Doctor gambit, stepping forward to be the Unzal’s ambassador to the powers that be, and there’s an utterly barnstorming performance from Misha Malcolm as Sergeant ‘Nicki’ Attah, described as a relief for Benton. We’d very much like more of Sergeant Attah, please and thank you, and ultimately, we’d like her to be Brigadier of UNIT North or somesuch, second only to Lethbridge-Stewart himself. We’d like that because Malcolm’s performance is fresh, and vibrant, and a joy to listen to, and because she feels like a paving of the way for the likes of a young Winifred Bambera to come up through the ranks. More. Please. Thank you.

In all fairness though, we could ask for more of almost everything in this story. More of the effortless chemistry between Culshaw and Treloar (adjusted slightly in this story so that it reflects that first Pertwee season with its sizing up of each other). More Daisy Ashford, any time she’s free and the stories can be written for her. And more hardcore UNIT action stories like this one, to sweep us along and make us eat popcorn as the episodes power by us one after another with a pulse-raising punch and purpose.

And then there’s The Gulf.

Two more dissimilar stories it would be hard to even devise, but you won’t be chewing popcorn listening to Tim Foley’s tale of serious psychological horror.

You’ll be too busy biting your nails.

There’s a whole different atmosphere here, as Foley takes the Third Doctor and Sarah-Jane (again played by the daughter of the original actress, in this case Sadie Miller) to an artistic retreat with several serious differences. A platform on a giant lethal ocean, occupied solely by women artists, presided over by Marta Malvani, a seemingly past-her-prime artist, who now mostly guides the works of others. In a mark of staggeringly ironic casting, Marta Malvani is played by Wendy Craig, an actress of legendary status and power, whose prime is not only here and now, but has been enduring in one form and another for decades. You could more or less stop reading once you know Wendy Craig is in The Gulf and be assured of its quality.

But there’s so much more to say. This thing is creeeeepy. Rivulets down the wall, water-monsters talking you to death, old secrets rising to the surface, complex relationship drama creeeeeepy.

Tim Foley always has a dab hand with his scripts of getting you to buy into the character-chemistry, but this is a story so immersive, so multi-faceted, you may need a good brisk walk in the sunshine once you’re done with it, just to restore your equilibrium. That’s only right for a story where the villain seems to ooze into you from the walls, from the air, from the drinking water, and from every conversation you have.

Imagine a situation where the air you breathe became both insidious and aggressive, wanting to trip you into one reaction. One obvious reaction, and then you die. Don’t blink. Don’t move. Don’t breathe…

This is a story very much in a 21st century vein, but starring the Third Doctor and Sarah. It’s very distinctly an evolution of the kind of story that could have – and would have – been told on TV during their era, but the character chemistry between the two of them remains true to that Seventies model.

It would be utter folly to try and explain all the backstory of The Gulf to you – and besides, it would ruin the experience for you. But in the foreground suffice it to say that one of the young artists on the platform falls into the deadly sea, and is missing, presumed about as dead as you can imagine.

And then she comes back.

The creepy suspicions that begin to drip into every conversation are what powers The Gulf along, and when the truth is finally revealed, it’s so very worth the wait. As with Daisy Ashford’s Liz Shaw in The Unzal Incursion, there’s at least one scene in The Gulf which is pure Sarah-Jane, of the kind you’d have paid good handfuls of salary to have seen on screen. Slightly weirdly, they’re both scenes of companion-torture. But where Liz is tortured physically, and you hear her magnificent resistance, Sarah-Jane gets the psychological treatment, and it reveals something about the relationship between our favourite journalist and her ever-absent Aunt Lavinia that will help put them both in a brand new light.

The Unzal Incursion is full-on early UNIT action adventure that will get your pulse pounding. The Gulf, by way of utter contrast, is a clammy, claustrophobic terrorfest, probably way too dark for TV at the time, but absolutely up there with the likes of The Chimes of Midnight in the sustained atmosphere and chilly finger up the spine stakes.

Both of the stories in this box set could well be thought of as masterpieces in their own right. The cast is spot on, anchored by Tim ‘Flawless’ Treloar, and you’ll come out the other side of this box set believing you’ve just been through a Third Doctor kaleidoscope of moods – and loved every minute of it.

Monday, 6 July 2020

Who Reviews The Time Monster by Matt Rabjohns



"Welcome! Welcome to your new Master!"

The Doctor is having the grandmother of all nightmares as we join this story, The Time Monster. Volcanoes and earthquakes rage on in a very very strong opening scene. These then dissolve away into a picture of the Doctor slumped on a sofa, besides a massive glowing trident shaped crystal. A flash of lightning and the Doctor, played suavely and amazingly by Jon Pertwee, awakes, seriousness and horror etched on his features. Then he looks up to see the Master, as ever sublimely portrayed by Roger Delgado who utters these commanding words. Then the Doctor wakes up. Wow, what a brilliant opening scene. I remember thinking this scene was truly filmic when I first watched it as a kid!

What follows on from this memorable opening scene is a story packed with some extremely strong ideas, only slightly hampered by some not quite so brilliant effects. But the story is definitely ambitious, and has a massive epic quality to the storytelling none the less. The Time Monster wonderfully weaves some of the best-known Greek myths together in a very satisfying cake that is brilliant to watch from the get go.

First let's talk about the cast of this story. It is extremely strong. Ingrid Pitt for beginners stuns and impresses as the Atlantean Queen Galleia. Her scenes together with Roger Delgado are absolutely priceless scenes. I love scenes where the Master is using his suave charm to bend people to his will. Ingrid is superb in this role, and her final scene of looking on as Kronos the Chronovore reduces her city to rubble makes for a very powerful final image of the ancient city of Atlantis.

George Cormack is superb as King Darius, and his scenes where he talks with the Doctor are just as good as Roger's with Ingrid. George gives so much realism and pathos to the doomed King, and his final scene is touching and deeply moving indeed.

I dont think one will see many people ever dwell on the character of Lakis, portrayed incredibly wonderful by Susan Penhaligon. I absolutely love her character and how she instantly strikes up such a strong and firm rapport with Katy Manning's Jo. I love the scenes of them creeping about Atlantis spying on the Queen. I only wish that she had been in more stories. This unassuming yet brave girl deserved even to become a companion if you ask. Oh well, I suppose one has to be glad of them being in one episode I suppose.

Its brilliant beholding the sublime costume and makeup of the wonderful Dave Prowse as the Minotaur. In fact, I would state he portrays one of the very best Minotaur's I've ever seen in any film or TV programme. The makeup is fantastic. His Bull head is absolutely exquisitely designed. Its again such a shame he didn’t get a few more scenes!

Wanda Moore and Ian Collier are absolutely a class double act as Ruth Ingram and Stewart. I love that Ruth is absolutely a feminist, and one loves some of the one liners she has throughout this story. They make a memorable couple of scientists and Ian is particularly superb when in his aged form, he gives a superb performance when he sees his old man face in the mirror.

John Wyse is wonderful as the easily controlled and manipulated Dr Percival. His scenes with Roger Delgado are amazingly good.

This story is also a very strong one for both John Levene's Benton and Richard Franklin's Mike Yates. In fact, this story yet again has an extremely fine cliff-hanger to part three where the Master drops the WW2 doodlebug on the UNIT troops transporting the TARDIS through the woods. This is a superb scene indeed and one that stayed in my mind a long time after watching.

It's a shame that the make up of Kronos doesn't work so well as the rest of the story does. The strange helmeted bird fails to ever really be convincing. And the much better adopted form of Ingrid Bower as the female face of Kronos in the final scene is let down because of this being her only scene in the role, so she doesn't really have much at all to work with, and this is a shame as she still manages to steal the scene.

However, one slight oddity is that at the end of the scene Roger Delgado perhaps gives a somewhat starkly uncharacteristic grovelling scene to the Doctor which fails to convince, it’s totally at odds with his otherwise superb performance throughout the rest of the story. But it’s the only time I thought Roger could have done it a bit better, otherwise in every story he was utterly formidable in the role of the Master.

And the Doctor's daisiest daisy scene would rank high up as one of the Third Doctor's defining moments. There is no way Jon Pertwee could have delivered the scene any better than he did either. It's a sublime scene and so beautifully performed indeed.

The Time Monster is a thoroughly excellent six parter. However, there is just one other slight annoyance with this story. This story for some reason, is a lot more jarring between its studio scenes and film scenes. In this story the filmed sequences are extremely effective, and when paired with the studio scenes this time it's a little distracting at times. I think this story would have benefited greatly in being shot completely on film.

This is only a minor niggle though. This story is imaginative, creative and with the the abbreviation TOMTIT highly amusing indeed. The whole concept of Time Ram too is a bonkers little addition to the mix. This makes the Time Monster a very strong, if slightly flawed entry to the Doctor Who canon.

And, oh yes, how can one end this review without a mention of John Levene's intense embarrassment as the now grown up Benton in nothing more than a nappy to close the story on a very very memorable way?! Priceless stuff.

Thursday, 4 June 2020

Who Reviews The Sea Devils by Matt Rabjohns



The Sea Devils may well truly deserve the mantle of the quintessential Jon Pertwee era story. It has every vital ingredient. It has Jon Pertwee on extremely fine form indeed, and he is complemented and truly aided by Katy Manning as the awesome Jo Grant. It also boasts one of Roger Delgado's very finest outings as the Master. He always was the perfect Moriarty to Jon's Sherlockian Doctor. And this story for once does give us just a bit of a breather from the usual UNIT flavoured background of almost every other Jon Pertwee Earth bound adventure. ​
Yet again Malcolm Hulke writes a story that delivers rich characterisation and this is never once at the expense of plot. It is assured and confident writing. Which is hardly surprising seeming as Mac was always one of the most gifted classic era writers. He tended to write many characters you cared for while watching. And what Mac also possessed was the pen for also writing grey and selfish characters too that one loves to loathe. In the Sea Devils it’s the snivelling Parliamentary Private secretary whom one really loves to detest in almost every way. ​
The Sea Devil design was one to give me nightmares. one can see their look is based on turtles but for some reason when I was young, they scared the pants of me and then some. Although I think the memorable and highly effective score from the Radiophonic workshop aided my nightmares. The score of this story works extremely well, and is definitely an experimental approach that succeeds. Several scenes indeed are laced with palpable menace and are branded onto my memory because of this. ​
Michael Briant's direction is superb within this story. There are several superb scenes. There is even the smallest amount of pathos when the Doctor recalls to Jo at he and the Master once being such good friends and his sadness at how that has changed. Then there is the very impressively choreographed sword fight between Jon and Roger which leads to a memorable climax for part two. (Aside from the sandwich that falls off the table then miraculously jumps back onto the table a second later!) ​
Declan Mulholland particularly deserves praise for his role as the frightened sea fort worker Clark. He is superb in his display of total fear at being attacked and cornered by a sea devil. A superb scene follows as the Doctor uses his jiggery pokery to set up a trap and thus drive the sea devil off. It’s actually a shame he couldnt have been in the story just a little longer. But one is glad that he survives the story and makes it out alive! When he turns his head towards the darkness and sees the sea devil, I was well and truly scared out of my noggin when I first watched this scene. ​
This story's cast are all memorable and confident and competent. The pace of the story is extremely well maintained too and yet again just not feel like nearly two and half hours’ worth of TV. Clive Morton is robustly sublime as the troubled Trenchard, who ends up paying the price for being a cohort of the devious Master. His sense of betrayal when he learns of what the Master's plans really are do a nice little flip and make one feel sorry for him in his final moments as he defends the prison from the invading sea devils. ​
Edwin Richfield too is excellent as Captain Hart. In that he portrays a military naval man, but he's not a complete bumbling idiot and he does know when to listen to the Doctor in the end. June Murphy too copes easily and very well with the could have easily been thankless role of Jane Blythe and somehow makes her seem far more of a character than she may have come across as if done in any way differently! ​
However there maybe is just one small sore point for me with this story. Sometimes the force of the resistance of the enemy takes its toll on the Doctor, and here is a classic example of it at the climax of this story. In the Silurians the Doctor was incensed that the Brigadier would seal the Silurians into their base in Wenley Moor, effectively wiping them out. His moral stab at the Brigadier in that story's final scene was one of the Third Doctor's finest moments. But even with the knowledge that the Sea Devils will not broker a peace with the humans, the third Doctor is rather two faced here as he blows up the Sea Devil base, and then he somewhat lamely announces that he did this to prevent a war. But to me this seemed rather hypocritical for a man who had previously chided the Brigadier for doing the self-same thing to the Silurian’s. But then again war is never easy is it? War is useless and sometimes in the darkest moments there is no happy outcome that can be brought. ​
The human’s butchery of the sea devils with guns and depth charges smacks of total realism to me too. If there were such creatures on the planet the plot seems highly believable in that this scenario seems very like what humanity would do if they suddenly had to share the planet with others. Maybe this story has a few Politically Correct moments. Although I prefer to call them moral overtones myself. I for one delight in good moral food for thought from a story and Malcolm Hulke's stories always deliver them in abundance. ​
The location works well and there are plenty of brilliant moments of tension and fear as this almost perfect story unfolds. Its little wonder this story is so highly regarded. It may not be quite as forceful in its moral ambiguity as Doctor Who and the Silurians, but it still gets its message over loud and clear. ​
Yes, it’s no surprise this story is seen as a true gem of the Jon Pertwee era.